Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Prediction & Betting Tips

Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Match Preview

Columbus Crew and New York Red Bulls meet again after a run of close encounters in Major League Soccer.

Both sides are fighting to finish strong and arrive with different momentums. Columbus remain tough to beat at home, while the Red Bulls continue to mix solid performances with sudden lapses away from home.

Columbus Crew Looking to Regain Edge After Tight Results

The Crew’s recent games show plenty of fight but not enough wins. They have drawn twice in their last three outings, including 1-1 results against Orlando and Toronto. However, lapses in concentration have cost them points, as seen in the 2-0 loss to Chicago and the 3-2 defeat at New York City.

At home, the Yellow and Black remain dangerous going forward, scoring in most of their recent matches. Their 4-5 away win at Atlanta earlier in September underlined their attacking depth, but defensive instability continues to follow them.

With 52 goals scored but 50 conceded in 33 games, they rarely play low-scoring matches.

New York Red Bulls Seeking Consistency on the Road

The Red Bulls enter this fixture after a frustrating spell. They fell 0-1 to FC Cincinnati last time out and were edged 3-2 by New York City. Even so, their 2-0 win away to Montreal showed they can perform when space opens up.

Their away form remains unpredictable. In five recent outings, they have managed only one clean sheet. With 47 goals scored and 44 conceded this season, they stay competitive but often lose shape late in matches.

Historically, trips to Columbus have been difficult, with several draws and narrow losses in the last few meetings.

Smart Insights by LeagueLane®

• Four of the last six meetings between these sides featured Over 2.5 goals.
• Columbus have seen both teams score in four of their previous five games.
• New York Red Bulls failed to win any of their last three away fixtures.
• The most recent meeting in August ended 0-0, breaking a streak of high-scoring clashes.

Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Prediction

This matchup promises goals. Both teams carry attacking intent but leak heavily at the back. Columbus have shown more balance at home and tend to control games through sustained pressure. Their scoring record suggests they can find multiple goals again, especially against a Red Bulls side that often concedes in clusters.

Expect an open contest where the hosts eventually pull clear. The betting tip of Over 3.5 goals aligns well with both teams’ recent trends and defensive issues. Given the Crew’s superior home record and sharper attack, a 3-1 victory for Columbus fits the pattern of this fixture.

Finn Larsson- October 17, 2025

Columbus Crew vs New York Red Bulls Betting Tips

Over 3.5 goals

OK

2.40 Odds

Columbus Crew 3-1

OK

12.00 Odds